Monday, July 28, 2008

The Cat and Mouse Race

A couple of nights ago, to celebrate the weekend, 7 of us sat together and played Poker. The game was interesting and went on till about 3:30 in the morning. We were all hungry and wanted to wait till Thadambail opened. While waiting for time to pass somebody remarked on the fact that how an MBA can change your life. One thing led to another and we ended up at the topic of CAT going online when my batch writes it. That's what 'the race' is about and I wanted you all to think about the difference this will create. In the last few years the CAT has been referred to as the most competitive exam in the world. With percentages of people getting in with respect to the number of people attempting very low, its supposed to be harder to get in to an IIM than to any of the Ivy Business Schools. So since, the CAT is going online next year, we were discussing what all the pros and cons of this would be. For one it is easier for the organisers to hold it because it will cut out the labourious and expensive tasks of transportation and correction. One of the more important aspects is that there will be no more of paper leaking and other unscrupulous things figuring in the scheme of things. The test is to follow the adaptive pattern that GRE and GMAT follows, except that a score will not be given immediately after the end of the test. It remains to be seen whether the percentile system will still be used, because technically percentile talks about the number of people you did better than in a particular test. Since everybody does not take the same test, percentile may not be apt. The adaptive pattern has its own advantages and disadvantages. It's better than the written paper in a sense that its more accurate in testing a person's intelligence. But, it also depends on the first few questions, so if someone screws up there, it might not be the best test for him. CAT has always been about speed and time management. Nobody knows how this will work. With the adaptive system you cannot comeback to or skip a particular question, so it might not be about speed anymore. Besides this, there is the psychological feeling about being more comfortable with a pen in hand and solving a paper than clicking answers on a mouse. I want to know what's your take on this, do you think the online system is better? or its better to have the good old pen and paper test. Will the 'cat race' be any different once you have to use the mouse to catch the CAT? Only time will tell.

10 comments:

KAKA said...

Well I hate the GRE and its dumb pattern...its bloody irritating to sit in front of a comp that long!!!I love the idea of a pen in the hand...but i guess its because we ve been taught that way...if cat changes then i think our great profs should learn to help us the comps more than the paper :)

Layfield said...

computer computer computer computer

Bhargav said...

Thoughts flow better with pen in hand.

As MV mentions, an adaptive paper will be disasterous, unless they do away with the speed-acccuracy criteria ,and make it more understanding and application based like the GRE.

Vikram said...

Pen and paper... any day

Prufrockster said...

Thank you for the gyan :P

--

It's better than the written paper in a sense that its more accurate in testing a person's intelligence.

?!

--

nhpwhc

Half-Light said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Half-Light said...

The adaptive pattern is more accurate because everybody does not answer the same test, and some people might get lucky with the paper. It is not 'the' best form, but certainly more accurate than the written round.

Prufrockster said...

I'm dumb. I still don't get why the online system is more accurate.

If being lucky's the black sheep, in the written test, then in the All New Online CAT, X can get a difficult paper, and Y can get an easier paper. X has good luck, Y has bad luck. That doesn't change anything.

I'm pretty sure I didn't understand what you mean.

And I like Online tests better.

Half-Light said...

No, there is no question of luck in the online version. See, the way these things work is that the first question is a question that someone in the 50th percentile(average) student should be able to answer. And if you get that right, you get a tougher question(maybe 55) and if you get it wrong it goes one difficulty level below. Hence there is no question of luck. If you are good, you are good. And if you are bad, you are bad. Is it any clearer? Or am I doing a pathetic job? lol

Mirage said...

The question among the mice is : "Who will bell the CAT??" Or it will keep gobbling down,not the mice, but the janitors of the mice..